Article 1.026 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) establishes that the opposition to declaration injunctions interrupts the time limit for the filing of other appeals. Despite the legal provision, jurisprudence admits situations in which this effect is avoided, generating uncertainties regarding the counting of the appellate time limits.
The issue gains special relevance when the assessment of the applicability of the injunctions occurs after their opposition. In these cases, the party may discover, only after the main appeal has been filed, that the time limit was not considered interrupted.
This was the scenario faced by the Special Court of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) during the trial of the Contradictory Amicable Applications in Special Appeal (EAREsp) No. 2.691.422/RJ in September 2026.
The divergence on the suspensive effect of declaration injunctions
The case originated from a judgment issued by the Rio de Janeiro Court of Justice (TJ/RJ). The appellant filed declaration appeals, pointing out omissions and contradictions in aspects of the decision.
However, the RJ Supreme Court did not hear the appeals because it considered that the defects had not been indicated. Subsequently, the Third Chamber of the STJ considered the special appeal submitted by the party to be untimely, on the grounds that the appeals not heard would not have interrupted the appellate period.
The dispute submitted to the Special Court opposed two understandings. In the judgment under appeal, the Third Chamber held that appeals for declarations not known, especially when manifestly inadmissible, do not interrupt the appeal period. However, in the paradigm judgment, the Second Chamber stated that “the declaration injunctions, although not known, but tempestuous, interrupt the time limit for filing an appeal”.
The divergence has brought to the discussion an important question for contentious practice: under what circumstances the non-knowledge of declaration injunctions can invalidate the suspensive effect provided for in the CPC?
What did the Special Court of the STJ decide?
In the EAREsp No. 2,691,422/RJ trial in September 2026, the Special Court recognized, by 12 votes to 1, the timeliness of the special appeal.
The decision reaffirmed that the suspensive effect of declaration injunctions can be lifted when the appeal is untimely, manifestly inadmissible, or filed without indicating any of the defects provided for in Article 1.022 of the CPC.
On the other hand, the mere fact that the court considers the alleged defects to be nonexistent is not sufficient to preclude the interruption of the appeal period.
This understanding is supported by a precedent recorded in the dissenting opinion of the Minister-Rapporteur:
“(…) rejection or non-knowledge for reasons of merit or defect do not remove the suspensive effect, provided that the opposition is timely.” (REsp 2.170.171/PR, rel. min. Moura Ribeiro, Third Chamber, DJEN of 27/11/2025)
This distinction was decisive for the outcome of the trial.
Although the RJ Supreme Court formally declared that it was unaware of the appeals, the party had explicitly indicated omissions and contradictions. In assessing the existence of these defects, the court of origin conducted, in the understanding of the Special Court, an “genuine examination of merit”.
Thus, the lack of formal knowledge of the injunctions could not, by itself, prevent the interruption effect from occurring.
Legal certainty and predictability for parties and lawyers
Although the Special Court recognized the suspensive effect in the specific case, the judgment maintained exceptions to the rule provided for in Article 1.026 of the CPC.
We understand, however, that only impertinence should avert this effect.
Timeliness constitutes an objective criterion, verifiable at the time the injunctions are filed. The assessment of their adequacy or the adequacy of the grounds for them, however, depends on a subsequent judicial evaluation.
Conditioning the interruption of the appeal period to this assessment means transferring to the parties a risk that they cannot control in advance.
The consequence is a reduction in procedural predictability: even after the timely opposition of the objections, the party may remain uncertain as to the interruption of the time limit for the main appeal.
This foundation was highlighted in the vote of Minister Raul Araújo:
“If the interruption depends on a later judgment by the judge on the ‘quality’ of the objections, the lawyer will never know for certain whether the time limit for the main appeal is running or not.”
The discussion therefore goes beyond the specific case and highlights the risks of conditioning an immediate procedural effect on a subsequent judicial assessment, compromising legal certainty and the predictability of appeal deadlines.
What care should be taken in practice?
While the understanding reaffirmed by the Special Court in the case under review prevails, the formulation of the declaration of objections requires special attention to the identification and substantiation of the alleged defects.
To reduce procedural risks, it is recommended to:
- Explicitly identifying the addiction: clarify whether the decision contains omission, contradiction, obscurity, or material error, in accordance with Article 1.022 of the CPC.
- Indicate the portion of the decision that is being challenged: demonstrate specifically where the indicated addiction is located.
- Explaining its impact: present the relevance of the issue for the understanding or integration of the decision.
- Formulate the request clearly: specify the remedy intended through the declarations of embargoes.
Until the matter is resolved, it is also advisable to exercise caution when calculating the time limit for the main appeal.
The importance of following the evolution of jurisprudence
Although the Special Court has reaffirmed the circumstances in which the suspensive effect can be waived, the interpretation of Article 1.026 of the CPC still requires caution when calculating the time limits for appeals.
Maintaining exceptions based on the adequacy and the merits of the objections still requires caution on the part of professionals working in litigation.
For this reason, keeping track of the evolution of the STJ’s jurisprudence and adopting rigorous criteria in the drafting of appeals are important measures for preserving legal certainty and reducing risks in the conduct of the proceedings.
Civil Litigation / Dispute Resolution
The Civil Litigation / Dispute Resolution area of the Fialdini Einsfeld Advogados (FEADV) It acts in the conduct of litigation before the Federal Judiciary and the Higher Courts, monitoring the evolution of jurisprudence and its impact on the procedural strategy, the admissibility of appeals and the management of appellate deadlines.