Deprecated: ob_end_flush(): Producing output from user output handler TRP_Translation_Render::translate_page is deprecated in /home3/car70439/feadv.com.br/wp-includes/functions.php on line 5581
Special resource relevance filter: what changes in practice? - Fialdini Einsfeld Advogados

Special feature relevance filter: what changes in practice?

Regulated in 2026, the relevance filter alters the admissibility of the special appeal. Understand the requirements and initial application by the STJ.
Published on: November 4, 2026
5 minute read

The Superior Court of Justice (STJ) is experiencing an increase in the volume of cases. In the first half of 2026 alone, the Court received approximately 260,000 cases¹. This scenario reinforces the need for mechanisms capable of rationalizing the judicial activity and preserving the institutional function of the Tribunal, responsible for uniformizing the interpretation of federal legislation that is in conflict with the Constitution.

It was in this context that Constitutional Amendment No. 125, of July 14, 2022, established the relevance of the federal law issue as a requirement for the admissibility of the special appeal. The regulation was made by Law No. 15,484 of August 4, 2026², and by Regimental Amendment No. 55/2026 of the STJ³, which adapted the Court's Internal Regulations to the new system.

 

What is the relevance filter?

The model bears similarities to the institute of res judicata, which is required for the adjudication of extraordinary appeals. In both cases, the goal is to select issues that go beyond the subjective interests of the parties and present economic, political, social, or legal significance, justifying the actions of the Superior Courts.

With the inclusion of Article 1.035-A in the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), the petitioner must demonstrate, in a specific and substantiated paragraph, the relevance of the federal legal issue submitted to the STJ’s consideration, proving that it exceeds the scope of the parties’ interests.

 

What happens if the relevancy is not recognized?

The absence of demonstration of relevance in the specific topic implies the inadmissibility of the special appeal, in accordance with Article 1.035-A, § 3, of the CPC.

The STJ’s failure to recognize the relevance depends on the constitutional quorum of two-thirds of the members of the competent adjudicating body, as stipulated in Article 1.035-A, § 6º of the CPC.

The decision that is not subject to special appeal for lack of relevance is not subject to appeal, according to the chapeau of Article 1.035-A of the CPC.

 

Hypotheses of presumed relevance

The Federal Constitution, in its Article 105, § 3, establishes circumstances in which the relevance of the federal issue is presumed, among them:

  • Criminal actions;
  • Actions of administrative misconduct;
  • Shares whose value exceeds 500 minimum wages;
  • Actions that may lead to disqualification;
  • Cases in which the judgment appealed contradicts the dominant jurisprudence of the STJ.


The presumption, however, does not exempt the applicant from addressing the relevance in a specific and substantiated topic, and it is up to him to demonstrate the framework of the controversy within one of these hypotheses.

 

Main effects of the recognition of relevance

The recognition of relevance may lead to the formation of a qualified precedent, with the establishment of a legal thesis that is mandatory to be followed, in accordance with Article 927, paragraph III-A, of the CPC.

However, this does not automatically occur in every case. The new regime also allows for the consideration of special appeals with effects limited to the specific case.

 

The rule is already being used

The practical application of the new regime has already begun.

On October 7, 2026, the Second Section of the STJ unanimously recognized the relevance of the issue regarding the possibility for the condominium to impose on the defaulting condominium owner the contractual attorneys' fees resulting from the filing of a lawsuit to collect condominium dues (REsp nº 2.273.471)⁴.

The controversy also covers the legal distinction between this hypothesis and the one regarding the charging of fees resulting from the lawyer’s extrajudicial activities.

Although other issues had already been admitted under the new system, this was the first controversy in which a majority was formed in favor of recognizing their relevance in the virtual sessions dedicated to the new regime.

In this case, the suspension of special appeals and appeals in special appeals that discuss the matter, which are currently pending in the courts of origin and in the STJ itself, was determined.

The merits of the matter will be heard in person at a hearing.

 

The challenge of reconciling relevance and access to extraordinary jurisdiction

The implementation of the relevance requirement inaugurates a new stage in the Court’s work before the STJ. With this mechanism, it is intended to direct the Court’s activity to legal issues whose resolution can contribute to the uniformity of the interpretation of federal legislation and to legal certainty.

Despite this purpose, the implementation of the new requirement raises questions regarding the definition of the criteria for the recognition of relevance.

Although the legislation sets out general parameters, identifying the issues that effectively go beyond the subjective interests of the parties involves a margin of discretion whose concrete application will depend on the Court’s jurisprudential construction.

In this scenario, the lack of sufficiently clear guidelines can increase the subjectivity of the admissibility review and create another obstacle to the knowledge of special resources.

The challenge, therefore, will be to reconcile the need to select the controversies that justify the Court’s action with the predictability that should guide the appellate system.

The consolidation of objective and transparent criteria, accompanied by consistent reasoning in admissibility decisions, will be essential to avoid different treatment of similar issues and ensure that the requirement serves its purpose without unduly restricting access to the uniform adjudication body.

 

 

References

[1] Superior Court of Justice. Relevance of the federal issue: what changes in the STJ’s work with the new system. 30 August 2026. Consult source.

[2] Brazil. Law No. 15,484 of August 4, 2026. It includes Article 1.035-A and Article 927, subsection III-A, of the Code of Civil Procedure. Consult the legislation.

[3] Superior Court of Justice. Regimental Amendment No. 55/2026. Consult the document.

[4] The Second Section, unanimously, recognized the existence of the relevance of the issue of federal non-constitutional law, based on Articles 255-C, I, and 255-L of the RISTJ, for the examination of the following controversy:

“to determine whether the contractual legal fees expended by the condominium for the filing of a judicial action aimed at collecting condominium dues may be attributed to the defaulting condominium owner, as well as whether there is a legal distinction between this situation and that concerning the fees arising from the lawyer’s extrajudicial activities.”

It also determined the suspension of special appeals and appeals in special appeals pending in the courts of origin and the Superior Court of Justice, which concern the same legal issue, in accordance with article 1.035-A, § 7, of the CPC, in accordance with the vote of the Minister President of the Management Committee of Precedents.

Others
perspectives